
Including an album like this in the Fruit Tree Records albums of the year feature is a little like picking a year from the sixties and praising a Beatles album as one of the best. It is rather stating the obvious with ‘In These Silent Days’ too because the acclaim showered upon it at the end of the year was plentiful. This is hardly a case of picking out a hidden gem that deserves a day in the sun. Well, what I would argue to that is twofold; firstly, there are many albums released on the major labels that receive accolades and high placements in end of year lists which are there more due to the strength of the marketing campaign rather than anything too remarkable in the actual music; secondly, I have a personal desire for all the records I rate strongly on a musical level to have a visible presence in the mainstream. Yes indeed, there is no old school style indie snobbery on display here, I really want great albums to top the charts every time.
‘In These Silent Days’ is an album born out of the early 2020 days of lockdown. As such, there is a heavy injection of introspection and open-hearted emotion. It just so happens though, that this is exactly where Brandi can massage your soul. She has been likened to many an early seventies singer-songwriter, but this is simply because she carries the flame for that era so well. Her sound is hand crafted and warm; her acoustic touch is sure and her lyrics have a directness to them that betray a deep understanding of the song writer’s craft. The opening trio of songs put all of these gifts in the front window display. ‘You And Me On The Rock’ (about Brandi and her wife, there’s a hint of CS&N’s ‘Our House’ in the breezy tone) and ‘This Time Tomorrow’ are superior ballads crying out for a writer to apply the word Americana to them (you’re welcome). However, it is opener ‘Right On Time’ that really grabs you by the collar. Referencing the album title, the way Brandi’s vocal takes off with the line “it wasn’t right, but it was right on time” letting loose a vibrato vocal to die for, this is clearly a performer putting everything she’s got into her song, listeners sit up and take notice at these moments.
It was with her second album, the 2007 release ‘The Story’, that Brandi Carlile showed a hint of a signature to her music. That was a volcano of power simmering inside her, a stunning strength in projection that she would allow to erupt exactly when a song demanded it. It is still there today and appears intermittently throughout ‘In These Silent Days.’ That vocal I referenced on track one certainly, but then ‘Broken Horses’ revs its engines in a similarly thrilling fashion as does ‘Sinners Saints And Fools,’ which explodes into a crescendo two thirds of the way through. But primarily for this release, it is the delicate touch and warm production undercoat that leave the strongest impression. ‘Letter To The Past’ has that rural ambience heard on the first McCartney solo album and ‘When You’re Wrong’ shows a little vulnerability mixed with grateful awareness in a gentle ode to “someone strong enough to love you when you’re wrong” (and it ends on a beautiful little chord change reminiscent of The Beatles ‘And I Love Her’). There are some great records that earn the acclaim thanks to the simple trick of presenting a great songwriter doing their thing and doing it extremely well. This is one such album, no gimmicks, no bullshit, just an amazing artist playing an incredible set of songs.
Get a vinyl pressing of the album here: https://www.discogs.com/release/20426491-Brandi-Carlile-In-These-Silent-Days







