
Ever since Elvis Costello, carving out a Jools Holland‑style TV‑presenter niche in the early 21st century, declared the 1980s “the decade that taste forgot,” it has almost been treated as fact. And while there are solid musical reasons not to revere the eighties the way we do the three decades before it, what is often overlooked is that it was the last time an underground scene truly meant something: alive with creativity, resistance, and a genuine DIY spirit invisible to the yuppies feeding their soulless numbers game. Punk had opened the doors to independence in the late seventies, and its ripples travelled far beyond the UK. In America they had the college‑radio circuit, with R.E.M. and their jangling brethren pushing back against the MTV onslaught. Simultaneously, by the mid‑eighties in England, “Indie” was becoming more than freedom from corporate control; it was becoming a sound. The Smiths may have defined it first: British guitar pop that used the instrument as a symbol of detached cool rather than phallic posturing. But as the movement gathered momentum, it increasingly felt like Scotland was where the real action was. North of the border, a musical fightback was brewing against expensive videos overshadowing songs, against synths draining the heart from the art form and in favour of rescuing beloved retro sounds from the scrap heap. And as this expansive three‑disc, 67-track set on Cherry Red Records, covering the final fifteen years of the century proves, there was far more to this movement than mere geography or Byrds‑influenced twelve‑string twee guitar pop.
We launch straight in with Jesus And Mary Chain from their 1985 debut LP with ‘You Trip Me Up.’ That is the sound of two worlds colliding right there. The C86 cassette from the following year may have captured the spirit of the scene, as well as some of its sixties influences but it did not impress on us the innovations some of these acts were instigating. The collision of aggressive feedback and classic girl-group pop melodies had not been heard before and for a time, the Mary Chain were as notorious as an act like Bob Vylan has become today. Nevertheless, this was more about music than attention seeking (even though the headlines the Reid brothers generated gave the pop landscape a welcome shot) and with the energy, attitude and pop-punk exuberance of The Shop Assistants up next, maybe this shows more the expected vibe for this collection; but nothing is quite so predictable on an engagingly curated set. The Soup Dragons sound feyer here than the indie-dance pioneers they are more widely remembered as and the same goes for Primal Scream. They are represented by ‘Gentle Tuesday,’ its golden chiming guitar solo showing just how expressive they were before beats and trippy remixes briefly took over. Still, the best finds come from names that have drifted from the conversation over time. The Motorcycle Boy are a good example of this, their ‘Big Rock Candy Mountain’ has alluring rockabilly style guitar phrases that deserved to push them (indie) chart bound.

The Big Gun take this thread further still; in fact, they had a member called Andrew O’Hagan whose semi-autobiographical memoirs about his time in the band were adapted into a BBC TV series. His group found strength in potent chorus repetition on ‘Heard About Love’ as do The Thieves on ‘Talk Your Head Off,’ although these hooks display more introspection. The fruity organ is pretty tasty too. Revolving Paint Dream celebrate the thrill of jingle-jangle riffage and happy surprises abound, like with The Jasmine Minks whose ‘Cut Me Deep’ is a strong contender for hit status in that parallel universe where all is right and just in the hit parade. Baby Lemonade have similar vim, their Syd Barrett referencing name being the only detail pointing to a psychedelic aesthetic. The Vaselines, who were later covered by Nirvana, offload exciting, trashy rock ‘n’ roll filth on ‘Teenage Superstar’ which is also the clearest pointer yet to the Velvet Underground’s quiet influence on large parts of this scene. And well-done Dawson for making a song called ‘Noel Edmunds’ that, even if the neatly bearded presenter were still radio broadcasting in 1989, he would not have been able to play his mainstream audience no matter how his ego may desperately have wanted to.
This is where the assumed story takes a lesser told turning, as bands like Fenn, Spirea X and The Fizzbombs push the harder, grey and industrial tones into the red reminding us that minor key guitar abuse is the sound of the eighties every bit as much as tinny synths and gated-reverb drums. Returning back to brighter guitars for disc two we launch with one of the C86 aligned, Sarah Records mainstay bands, The Orchids. Their ‘Something For The Longing’ is a distant cousin of R.E.M.s ‘King Of Birds’ (no bad thing) whilst The Wendy’s ‘Enjoy The Things You Fear’ recalls the nonchalance of indie-scene adjacent Lloyd Cole. Despite these reference points, the Pearlfishers ‘Sacred’ is arguably the purest period pop sound to be found here. The gospel-tinged lift in the chorus still hits with the same force it did thirty-five years ago. BMX Bandits ‘Serious Drugs’ resonates with the times too, as long at the times are 1992. This was the kind of festival hit that belonged to the indie culture and felt like an anthem. The sleevenotes actually informed us that it could have been a lot more successful had its release not coincided with ‘drugs awareness week.’ Still, the little George Harrison guitar punctuations are a charming nod and wink to a time when indelicate drug references in pop songs were almost obligatory.

The BMX Bandits Joe McAlinden did go on to get slightly more recognition (thanks to Rod Stewart covering one of his songs) and acclaim with his band Superstar who were signed to Creation Records. The track included here, ‘Don’t Wanna Die,’ does point to a far grander psychedelic pop and lush soft rock ambition lurking in the margins of the early nineties. Still, Dick Johnson stumbling in like the Cramps for ‘Disposable Darling’ also shows that the opposite also held true as some favoured unpolished, primitive energy. The compilation now hits a sequence revisiting the angular jerkiness of Whirling Pig Dervish then the chirp laced choppy guitar of Lung Leg. The Stanleys frantic craving precedes post-punk angst from Glue before Spare Snare’s trashcan scuzz. All these serve to highlight the enduring impression that these largely uncelebrated bands have left on so many familiarly arch guitar outfits of the present day. Moving on, Pink Kross barge in sounding like spiky haired psychobilly’s intent on elbowing anyone looking too bookish out of the way before Lugworm warn “better watch your back” in ‘Sweaty Says.’ I kept thinking they were referring to a certain disgraced and deceased BBC DJ but cannot find anything substantiating this, so it must just be my ears deceiving me.
This set is packed with highlights and more than a few buried jewels. The Poison Sisters ‘Chicane’ rocks a fat one with a crash-landing chorus and it is evident that, despite undeniable vintage influences, most of the recording here are the work of forward thinkers, not revivalists. That said, Luci Baines Band’s ‘Find A Lil Love’ is pure seventies good time rock but no less deserving of a 2026 resurrection. Arab Strap usher in, as we reach disc three, a late nineties golden age in which Aidan Moffat’s poetic kitchen sink reflections add a lyrical depth to the scene. The Delgados became darlings of the country thanks to their influential Chemikal Underground label, and their own John Peel endorsed boy / girl wistfulness; here though it is a more abrasive velvet fabric that is honoured on ‘Monica Webster.’ Today Belle And Sebastian’s ‘Lazy Line Painter Jane’ sounds like a solid gold indie pop classic with that yearning “last bus out of town” chorus but their commitment to the wider cause was full and detailed. For example, here was a band that properly honoured a trope, that by the nineties was often talked up but not as strictly observed as you might believe, of not putting single and EP tracks on albums. That was the case with this 1997 EP track, and I can still recall the delight as Belle And Sebastian fans organised their voting enough to shock the industry at the Brit Awards denying Steps a gong: a rare example of good music winning the day.

There are many more reacquaintances to indulge in too. Huckleberry are astonishing here, their lively dream‑pop melodies spinning effortlessly; then the booklet reminds me this was an early vehicle for James Yorkston, and suddenly everything clicks into place. The song ‘Three-Speed Wilfred’ was an unreleased 1999 recording so if there is not already enough inducement to check out this collection, you can add previously unheard tracks to the reasons too. Lovely to hear from King Creosote also, whose Fence Collective was an important turn of the century breeding ground. It also moved in parallel geographic strands to the ever-spectacular Beta Band, represented here by ‘Inner Meet Me’ from 1998. We close with a 1999 cut from Mogwai, one of an all too small number of bands featured who spectacularly broke out beyond the regions from which they arose. But to place too much importance on that misses the point, this celebration has never been about mass appeal. It has been a glorious carousel ride through an age defined by artistic momentum, single-minded character, and a belief in everything music can still do; a reminder that the tools of the trade remain basic, attainable, and utterly relevant. There is plenty here ripe for revival but set aside the big talk: ‘Something For The Longing’ is made for the finer feelings and asks for no wider stage. It stands as essential testimony to how the Scottish DIY movement struck gold with remarkable regularity.
Danny Neill
Get yourself a copy of ‘Something For The Longing’ here: https://amzn.to/42o06Hh














