
One thing that can derail my attempts to keep on top of new music releases at this time of year is the deluge of archive box set and deluxe editions that suddenly come out at roughly the same time. OK, you could argue that I do not have to listen to them, and it is true that many of these clearing out the archival cupboard sets only get played once. Something like The Beatles Anthology releases from thirty years ago, of which there will be remastered and expanded versions dropping before the end of the year, really contained very little in the way of essential additions to The Beatles body of work. It was all fascinating to hear but tracks that were still being learned or constructed in the studio, or different mixes halfway on their journey to full production, add nothing to your appreciation of The Beatles recorded output. It is like seeing a rough early development sketch of an esteemed artist’s famous masterpiece, interesting to get a glimpse of the creative process but you are never likely to return to it in preference to the completed work. The same applies to the Beatles Anthology, I regard myself as occupying the top tier of Beatles fanatics, but I can honestly say I have not listened to any of the Anthology this century; and I listen to The Beatles at some stage most weeks. This fact alone should ensure when the new Anthology arrives, regardless of whatever additional archival cherries have been dug up, it will feel like something fresh. This month I did check out the new remix of ‘Free As A Bird,’ which uses the same technology to enrich the lo-fi vocal recording of John Lennon as heard astonishingly on ‘Now And Then.’ My reaction was massively positive, not only did John’s voice seem a hundred times clearer, but the rest of the sound too, including the vocals recorded in 1994 by Paul McCartney and George Harrison, had far more body and texture to them. I would assume that on this occasion, the remix will become the standard version.
The problem is, at least in terms of time, that if the releases are from artists whose music you have had a relationship with for decades, you are going to want to make time for whatever comes out. Bob Dylan is as relevant to the music culture of our time as The Beatles and his long running archive releases,‘The Bootleg Series,’ is a shining example of how these kinds of projects should be curated. Still, it is absolutely mind blowing that there could be that much left to release, especially from his early years, but there obviously is because by the end of October the 18th volume of the series will arrive entitled ‘Through The Open Window 1956-1963’. Among the 8 CDs chronicling his early years in Greenwich Village we will hear rare and unheard home recordings, studio outtakes, coffeehouse, and nightclub shows all from brand new tape sources. The jewel in the archivist crown here will be an unreleased complete recording of Dylan’s landmark show at Carnegie Hall on October 26th, 1963, mixed from the original tapes. In terms of attracting the Dylanologist completists out there, with mouth watering contents such as these this release already sounds like the definitive early years of Dylan article. Most editions of the Bootleg Series feature Dylan recordings that can justify their place in the main canon of work thanks to his being a one off. Not many performers present themselves as they are feeling that very day quite like Bob does, his singular quest to capture spontaneous magic through exploration ensures any given concert recording might throw up something wonderful. That the opposite also applies is all part of the same fascination. In the studio he has never sought clinical perfection, more like real life reflecting soulful imperfection seems to be the aim. There are very few artists like this. Some might think they are, but Dylan trounces them all.
If ‘The Bootleg Series’ is the prime example on how to get this kind of thing right, then it should also be a measure to help siphon out the fool’s gold. I have written in the past on these pages about my love of the band Genesis, favoring the Peter Gabriel era but with an ever-growing acknowledgement that the Phil Collins years had some merit. Therefore, the recent appearance of Gabriel’s 1974 Genesis swansong album ‘The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway’ as a 50th anniversary deluxe edition inevitably has sparked some interest in me. Much has been made in the prog press of Gabriel and Tony Banks being photographed in the studio earlier this year working on the remaster. However, I have just been listening to it and honestly, despite giving it my best shot on quality audio equipment, I am struggling to spot any real impact of this rather over-hyped remastering. If anything, they might have lessened the punch in Phil Collins drums but even there, I cannot really spot any difference. Then, to add to the farce of it all, the 1975 two-disc concert recording included as part of the package is the exact same concert that took up the first two discs of Genesis’s 1998 ‘Archive’ box. OK, so maybe Gabriel and Banks were focusing on the Blu-ray audio 96/24 stereo mix and there are also three download only unreleased tracks from the sessions, but it does all feel a little elitist and over-sold. Especially when you consider the year long, anniversary missing delay around its eventual appearance. I would argue that the new box set I have enjoyed most this month, David Bowie’s ‘I Can’t Give Everything Away (2002-2016)’, sets a standard for how these releases can exquisitely compliment an artist’s catalogue. It is the sixth and final installment in a career spanning series of box sets that could be all you will ever need as an extensive Bowie career appreciation. Each focus on his career chronologically, includes all the original albums and singles from the period, all the live albums and relevant additional live recordings from the era and then devotes at least one disc to mopping up additional rare recordings, B-sides, and off cuts from that time as well. On top of it they have appropriate, well selected art and design, informatively written content, and authentically mastered sound quality. They really are collections that anyone taking a deep dive into the mans work will return to again and again, which is all you can wish for really.









